/
All articles

Good solutions

One manager – one responsibility

Employment points to a unit or cost center. When that responsibility is shared, employer responsibility turns ambiguous – and IT support unusable.

By Jens Fahlén · Published · 2 min read

In an HR register you almost never see an employee with two managers recorded. The problem shows up one step higher: the employment belongs to a certain unit or cost center, and it is that unit which has more than one manager.

A manager has three jobs: the work, the money and the people. When two managers are put on the same unit, it is mainly the people side – being the employer – that becomes unclear. Responsibility for staff follows where the person is employed.

Two ways to arrange responsibility for a unit

Good solution

One responsible manager per unit

UnitEmployeeManager

Employee with a manager code. Manager is not a separate information object. The red ring marks an Employee with a manager code, and the relationships state which unit, cost center or employees the person manages.

Explanation
The employee belongs to one unit, and the unit has only one manager with people responsibility.
Rationale
The chain is straight: employment, unit, one manager. Approvals, access and reports always get the same answer.

Less good solution

Two managers on the same unit

UnitEmployeeManagerManager

Employee with a manager code. Manager is not a separate information object. The red ring marks an Employee with a manager code, and the relationships state which unit, cost center or employees the person manages.

Explanation
Two managers are linked to the same unit where the employee works.
Rationale
You cannot tell who holds employer responsibility. Anyone asking the system gets two answers, and someone has to pick by hand every time.

Good solution

One responsible manager per cost center

Cost centerEmployeeManager

Employee with a manager code. Manager is not a separate information object. The red ring marks an Employee with a manager code, and the relationships state which unit, cost center or employees the person manages.

Explanation
The employee belongs to one cost center, and the cost center has only one manager responsible for both people and budget.
Rationale
The same straight chain: employment, cost center, one manager. Approvals and staff matters end up with the same person.

Less good solution

Two managers on the same cost center

Cost centerEmployeeManagerManager

Employee with a manager code. Manager is not a separate information object. The red ring marks an Employee with a manager code, and the relationships state which unit, cost center or employees the person manages.

Explanation
Two managers are linked to the same cost center where the employee works.
Rationale
Neither people nor budget responsibility is clear. Invoices and reports fall between two chairs.

What happens in the IT systems?

Systems meant to help managers and employees get no clear answer when responsibility is shared. Approvals stall or go to the wrong person, access cannot be added or removed automatically, and reports per manager either count people twice or miss them entirely.

You notice it most in everyday tasks: reporting time, approving expenses, holding performance reviews or ordering a computer and logins. There, the system always needs to know who decides.

The simple rule

What keeps things in order is simple: every employment belongs to a unit or a cost center, and there is one manager with people responsibility. Other leadership roles, temporary projects and shared daily work can be handled on the side – but they must never make it unclear who the employer is.

Cost centerEmployeeManager

Employee with a manager code. Manager is not a separate information object. The red ring marks an Employee with a manager code, and the relationships state which unit, cost center or employees the person manages.

Pattern C: employee and manager connected to a cost center.

Tags

  • #manager
  • #responsibility
  • #organisation

What did you think of this article?